Containers/Mini-summit 2008 notes

2008-07-22T15:08:26Z

Dhaval:

[[Category: Containers]]

Intros (8:36am)

Dave Hansen
Eric Biederman
Jason Byron, Red Hat
Joe Rusio, Evergreen
Joe McDonald
HP China
Sonny Rao
HP
HP
Matine Silberman HP
Sandy Harris
NEC Japan
John Schultz, AOL
Pavel Emelyanov, Parallels/OpenVZ
Denis Lunev, Parallels/OpenVZ
Constant Chan
Benjamin Thery, Bull
Daniel Lezcano, IBM
Serge Hallyn, IBM

On Phone:
Amy Griffith HP
Dhaval Giani, IBM

(Later walk-ins)

Topics:

Why do various companies want containers?
ibm: workload management
EB: using containers as improved chroot
HP: wants similar to ibm, plus security
parallels: hosted providers

sysfs issues
EB gives status: should go into next merge window

mini-namespaces
NFS
clients should behave differently on diff. containers
currently uses single sunrpc transport for all containers
Dave: is there a list of all openvz mini-ns?
EB:
proposal:
create little filesystems
still store everything in nsproxy
currently:
some people want same process in different netns's
almost possible now, but can't open new sockets
namespace enter:
3 purposes
login
monitoring
configuring
may be worth prototyping the proposal
address mqns, or sunrpc, or fuse?
DH:
openvz addresses this using one big clone(), right?
(yes)

userid namespaces
EB summarizes his proposal
userid ns is unsharable without privilege
userids, capabilities, security labels become ns-local
hierarchical like pidns
openvz: just does chroot
DH:
observers that system vs. app containers have different requirements
EB:
so with userid namespaces, user has god-like powers over created namespaces
EB+SH will talk about hacking something this week during ols
Uses:
user unttrusted mounts
build systems

device namespaces
tty namespaces rejected
should be solved with generic device namespaces
virtualize the major:minor->device mapping
reserved device numbers (unnamed)
created with /proc?
get_unnamed_device()
tty ideas:
use selinux ptys
use user namespaces
use legacy ptys
leverage ptyfs
Suka is not on, so he gets volunteered to do pure /dev/pts fs approach

per-container LSMs:
SH: thinks LSMs should handle it
EB:
original purpose of chroot
set up policies from inside container
creating smack container inside selinux would be ideal

entering a container
netns: identified using pid of a ns
sh: can we solve this using EB's namespace filesystems proposal?
(EB goes to the board to demonstrate his proposal)
PM: Can we use control groups?
PE: Can we re-use /proc/pid/ ?
EB: could have a ns with no processes in it
Example of command using this:
ip set eth0 netns <pid>
becomes
ip set eth0 netns /proc/<pid>/
DL:
a real netns problem is knowing when a childns has died
the netnsfs mount could solve that
PE: EB, can you send POC patches for the namespace?
EB and EM will both send their own POC.

DL: people have complained about needing CAP_SYS_ADMIN to unshare ns
EB: example, setuid root sysvipc-using program could be fooled

PE: Entering a container:
reasons:
monitoring
enter an administrative command
DH: how do you do it now?
PE: numerical ID for each VE, use it to enter
EB:
one need for entering: /sbin/hotplug
(someone): does hijack suffice?
EB: two cases:
partial entering
full entering
sys_hijack does not address partial entering
DH:
why need partial entering?
fs stuff can be done without entering
PM: privileged process
PE:
will look at hijack patches
someone will re-send hijack to containers@
EB:
if we can do sys_hijack cleanly,
we can use it to solve kthread problem

Containers/Mini-summit 2008

2008-01-31T08:17:53Z

Dhaval: /* List of attendees */

There are plans to organize a containers mini-summit at the OLS'08. This page is for organizing this mini-summit. Feel free to edit.

'''When''': before 23rd of July 2008 (on a day before the OLS itself)<br/>
'''Where''': Ottawa, ON, Canada.

== Proposal ==

A mini-summit proposal to be sent to OLS organizers. See [[{{PAGENAME}}/Proposal]].

== Topics to discuss ==

* Device accessibility cgroup (maybe with remap ability)
* TTYs
* Syslog
* Checkpoint/restart
* Memory controllers
* more?..

== List of attendees ==
Please fill in your name here if you are going to attend, or email kir at openvz dot org if you are too lazy. Surely the list is not final, so put your name even if you are not sure you can make it.

This list is in no particular order.


<div style="-moz-column-count:3; -webkit-column-count:3; column-count:3; text-align: left; background: #fefef0; border: 1px solid #ddddc0;">
# Kir Kolyshkin
# Pavel Emelyanov
# Denis Lunev
# Andrey Mirkin
# Serge Hallyn
# Dave Hansen
# Cedric Le Goater
# Daniel Lezcano
# Srivatsa Vaddagiri
# Balbir Singh
# Sukadev Bhattiprolu
# Paul Menage
# Eric W. Biederman
# Oren Laadan
# Yamamoto Takashi
# Kamezawa Hiroyuki
# Benjamin Thery
# Herbert Pötzl
# Oleg Nesterov
# Dhaval Giani
</div>

== Agenda ==

TODO

== See also ==
* http://www.linuxsymposium.org/2008/cfp.php — OLS call for papers
* https://lists.linux-foundation.org/pipermail/containers/2008-January/009688.html

[[Category: Containers]]
[[Category: Events]]

OpenVZ Virtuozzo Containers Wiki - User contributions [en]

Containers/Mini-summit 2008 notes

Containers/Mini-summit 2008